April 19, 2025 – New York, NY
In the city that never sleeps, one sports rivalry always stays awake: Yankees vs Mets. From the Bronx to Queens, from subway cars to sports bars, the question echoes louder than ever this season:
Who really owns New York baseball in 2025?
Two Franchises, One City, Endless Drama
The New York Yankees, with their legendary 27 championships, remain the global symbol of baseball dominance. But history alone doesn’t win games. Meanwhile, the Mets, long seen as the scrappy underdogs, have transformed into a legitimate powerhouse in recent seasons—thanks to bold spending, smart drafting, and a new swagger.
Both teams enter the 2025 season with high expectations. But the early numbers—and the city’s energy—suggest this may be one of the most competitive years in the Subway Series era.
The Bronx Bombers: Tradition Meets Transition
The Yankees are still led by Aaron Judge, who, at 33, continues to mash homers and lead the team with quiet authority. Around him, a new wave of youth is rising:
-
Spencer Jones, the 6’6” outfielder dubbed “Baby Judge,” is starting to shine.
-
Anthony Volpe, now a Gold Glove shortstop, has matured into a reliable middle-infield anchor.
-
The Yankees’ rotation, once again, is among the league’s best with Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodón, and emerging ace Chase Hampton.
But the Bronx isn’t without pressure. A lackluster postseason in 2024 left a sour taste, and fans are demanding results—not just tradition.
The Mets: A New Era in Queens
Meanwhile, in Queens, Steve Cohen’s Mets have shaken off the old stigma of failure. Under the leadership of new manager Craig Counsell, the Mets are playing with precision, aggression, and confidence.
-
Francisco Lindor is back to MVP form, electrifying both in the field and at the plate.
-
Pete Alonso continues his reign as one of MLB’s most feared power hitters.
-
The Mets’ pitching staff, even after the departure of veterans like Scherzer and Verlander, has been rebuilt with youth and fire, led by Kodai Senga and Christian Scott.
Perhaps most notably, the Mets are winning big games—something that has eluded them in recent years.
Head-to-Head: The Subway Series 2025
This season, the Subway Series will span two crucial weekends in June and August. Both series are already sold out, with resale ticket prices climbing over $300.
These matchups are more than just games—they’re battles for bragging rights, city pride, and momentum heading into the postseason.
All-Time Series Record (as of April 2025):
-
Yankees: 80 wins
-
Mets: 63 wins
-
Ties: 0
The Bronx still holds the edge, but the gap is narrowing.
Who Has the Edge in 2025?
| Category | Edge |
|---|---|
| Power Hitting | Yankees |
| Bullpen Depth | Mets |
| Infield Defense | Mets |
| Starting Pitching | Yankees |
| Base Running | Mets |
| Star Power | Even |
| Fan Energy | Even |
It’s a close call. But based on early-season form, many analysts are giving the slight edge to the Mets, citing their chemistry, hunger, and momentum.
What Fans Are Saying
“The Yankees are still kings until proven otherwise. But I’ll admit—this Mets team is scary good.”
— Chris, Bronx
“We’re not little brothers anymore. This is our year. Queens is rising.”
— Deja, Queens
Social media is on fire with debates, memes, and bold predictions. The city is divided—and loving every minute of it.
Final Take: Who Runs New York?
The truth? Both teams are elite. Both teams are dangerous. And both teams could meet in the World Series.
A Subway Series in the Fall Classic? Don’t laugh—it’s very possible.
But until October, the only thing that’s certain is this:
Baseball is alive and thriving in New York. And no matter who’s on top, the city wins.