Paul Finebaum Sends Stern Warning to Programs Targeting Nico Iamaleava

 

By Adam– April 15, 2025

College football's transfer portal continues to shake the landscape, and the latest earthquake comes courtesy of Tennessee quarterback Nico Iamaleava. The sophomore signal-caller, who led the Volunteers to a College Football Playoff berth just months ago, shocked fans and analysts alike by entering the transfer portal over the weekend.

The news has sparked a frenzy across the country, as top-tier programs scramble to secure a quarterback with elite arm talent, mobility, and playoff experience. But not everyone is sold on the idea that Iamaleava is the answer. In fact, ESPN’s Paul Finebaum offered a strong cautionary message to would-be suitors.

“This isn’t just about getting a five-star quarterback,” Finebaum said on his Monday morning segment. “It’s about making sure you’re not getting a player with one foot out the door the next time something doesn’t go his way.”

 A Rising Star at Rocky Top

Iamaleava started all 13 games last season for Tennessee, throwing for over 3,200 yards and 29 touchdowns while rushing for another six scores. His ability to extend plays and push the ball downfield helped the Vols secure an SEC Championship appearance and a berth in the College Football Playoff.

Although they ultimately lost to Ohio State in the first round, the sophomore QB was widely praised for his poise under pressure, and many believed he’d return to Knoxville as a potential Heisman candidate in 2025.

Instead, he’s on the move — and according to insiders, more than a dozen Power Five programs have already reached out.

 Finebaum: Buyer Beware

While many coaches are undoubtedly salivating over the chance to land a player of Iamaleava’s caliber, Finebaum pointed out that the transfer portal is a “double-edged sword,” particularly with quarterbacks.

“When a kid leaves a program after leading them to the playoff, it raises eyebrows. There’s more to this than meets the eye,” Finebaum added. “Coaches need to look deeper before just throwing a bag at him.”

Finebaum’s comments echo growing concerns within college football about player loyalty, NIL-driven decisions, and team culture, especially when quarterbacks are switching teams at historic rates.

What’s Next for Nico?

Speculation about where Iamaleava will land is rampant. Early whispers suggest interest from USC, Miami, and Oregon, with dark horse contenders like Texas A&M and even Notre Dame reportedly in the mix.

According to sources close to the situation, Iamaleava is looking for a system that allows him to showcase his dual-threat abilities and boost his 2026 NFL Draft stock. A fresh start may also help him escape the intense spotlight he’s faced at Tennessee since arriving as a five-star recruit.

 Reaction Around the SEC

Iamaleava’s decision has also sparked debate among SEC coaches and former players.

“It’s a new era,” said former LSU quarterback Matt Flynn on SiriusXM. “You can’t build a dynasty around a guy anymore unless you’re winning every year and paying top dollar. One bad season and they’re gone.”

Tennessee, meanwhile, is left reeling. With spring ball underway, head coach Josh Heupel must now turn to backup Gaston Moore or look to the portal himself to find a replacement.

 A New Chapter, But At What Cost?

Nico Iamaleava’s move may be the biggest story of the transfer portal cycle — and potentially the most consequential. While he has all the tools to become a top-tier college quarterback and future pro, Finebaum’s warning reminds us that talent isn’t everything.

In an era where mobility is currency and loyalty is negotiable, schools will need to weigh risk vs. reward carefully.