April 19, 2025 – New York, NY
New York is a city built on pride, passion, and rivalry. In baseball, it’s Yankees vs. Mets. In basketball, it's Knicks vs. Nets. And in Major League Soccer, it’s NYCFC vs. New York Red Bulls — a clash that’s become more than a local derby. It’s a fight for the soul of soccer in the Big Apple.
But beyond the rivalry, one big question looms for fans on both sides of the Hudson River:
Can either team finally bring lasting MLS glory to New York?
NYCFC: A New Era Begins
After winning their first MLS Cup in 2021, New York City FC has struggled to recapture that magic. But 2025 feels different. The club is in the midst of a rebuild-meets-rebirth, with new talent, a long-awaited stadium on the way in Queens, and a fresh tactical identity under head coach Nick Cushing.
Players to Watch:
-
Santiago Rodríguez continues to be the heartbeat of the midfield, combining flair and vision.
-
Jovan Mijatović, the Serbian striker signed in 2024, is finally finding form and leading the line with confidence.
-
James Sands has returned from Europe stronger than ever, anchoring the midfield with leadership and bite.
NYCFC is playing possession-heavy, fast-paced football, and despite a slow start to the season, they’re climbing the Eastern Conference table.
Red Bulls: Hungry and Re-energized
On the other side of the river, the New York Red Bulls are undergoing a transformation of their own. Known for their high press and relentless energy, 2025 has seen a more balanced, composed version of the team.
Head coach Sandro Schwarz, in his second season, has brought structure and stability to a club long defined by chaos. And it’s paying off.
Key Figures:
-
Emil Forsberg, the veteran Swedish playmaker, has added class and experience to a young squad.
-
Frankie Amaya is having a breakout season, dominating the midfield.
-
Dante Vanzeir, with improved consistency, is starting to deliver in big moments.
The Red Bulls are currently in playoff position and showing signs they can compete with the East’s elite.
The Rivalry: NYCFC vs. Red Bulls
The Hudson River Derby has grown into one of MLS’s fiercest showdowns. With packed stadiums, passionate chants, and dramatic finishes, it’s become a can't-miss event for New York soccer fans.
All-Time Derby Record (as of April 2025):
-
Red Bulls Wins: 13
-
NYCFC Wins: 9
-
Draws: 4
The Red Bulls still have the edge, but the gap is narrowing. The next derby, scheduled for June 8 at Red Bull Arena, is already being hyped as one of the most important in recent years — potentially a playoff decider.
MLS Cup Hopes: Can Either Go All the Way?
NYCFC’s Path:
-
Strengths: Young core, creativity in attack, improving defense.
-
Concerns: Inconsistency on the road, set-piece vulnerability.
-
X-Factor: Mijatović’s goal-scoring form.
Red Bulls’ Path:
-
Strengths: Organized defense, midfield dominance, depth off the bench.
-
Concerns: Struggles in big-game moments, past playoff failures.
-
X-Factor: Emil Forsberg’s leadership.
While neither club is a clear favorite to win MLS Cup right now, both have the potential to get hot at the right time. And with New York’s soccer scene more energized than ever, the pressure — and the spotlight — is on.
What the Fans Are Saying
“I’ve supported the Red Bulls since the MetroStars days. We’re overdue. This is our year.”
— Carlos R., Jersey City
“NYCFC is building something big. We’ve got talent, a future stadium, and a winning mentality. Watch us rise.”
— Lena M., Queens
Social media debates are heated, with fans exchanging predictions, banter, and a bit of trash talk. But one thing’s clear: soccer matters in New York like never before.
Final Take: Glory Up for Grabs
New York is ready. The clubs are rising. The rivalry is real. And while MLS glory has long felt just out of reach, 2025 might be the year one of these teams takes the leap from contender to champion.
Whether it’s NYCFC lighting up Queens or the Red Bulls turning Harrison into a fortress — soccer greatness in the Empire State feels closer than ever.
All that’s left is to prove it on the pitch.